| RTD Era Doctor Who - Poll the Third! |
[Jan. 31st, 2010|07:19 pm]
dalekboy
|
Yes, it's Series Three!
And while it may seem superfluous having separate favourite and least favourite for the companions, given there are only two, I've gone ahead and done it anyway!
Which were your favourite 3rd series stories?
The Shakespeare Code
0(0.0%)
Daleks in Manhattan / Evolution of the Daleks
1(4.0%)
The Lazarus Experiment
0(0.0%)
Human Nature / Family of Blood
1(4.0%)
Utopia / The Sound of Drums / Last of the Time Lords
0(0.0%)
Which were your least favourite 3rd series stories?
The Shakespeare Code
0(0.0%)
Daleks in Manhattan / Evolution of the Daleks
6(25.0%)
The Lazarus Experiment
2(8.3%)
Human Nature / Family of Blood
0(0.0%)
Utopia / The Sound of Drums / Last of the Time Lords
2(8.3%)
Who were your favourite companions for series 3?
Captain Jack Harkness
7(29.2%)
Who were your least favourite companions for series 3?
Captain Jack Harkness
6(40.0%)
Series 1 Poll
Series 2 Poll |
|
|
| Comments: |
If pushed, I couldn't actually pick a single favourite between "Blink" and "Human Nature". I think the former is a remarkable feat of sleight of hand, but I think that the latter has much more depth and actually makes for a better Doctor Who story.
I think Martha was a character they wrote pretty badly for the first half of the season, then I warmed to her and was actually a little sad to see her go. Jack Harkness... no, I could never give a positive vote for that character. Sigh...
Sadly, Martha annoyed me for most of the season, with all her pining after the Doctor. It was too soon after Rose. I think a much nicer way to handle it, if they felt they had to go that route, was to let Martha seem like an ordinary companion, albeit one who is fond of the Doctor, and then have it come out in Human Nature.
I liked Jack, but mostly because he was actually a much more enjoyable character to watch than he'd been on Torchwood. But even so, I didn't vote for either as a favourite. | |
slightly down, but not overly